best temperature for thermostat

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

As the seasons change, having a reliable thermostat becomes especially important. I’ve tested various models to find one that balances precision, ease of use, and versatility. The BN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller, Temperature stands out with its straightforward setup—just plug in, place the probe, and dial in your target temp. It’s rugged, with a bright display and indicator lights, so you can see everything even in dim settings. I’ve used it in greenhouses and garages, and its temperature accuracy within the 40–108°F range really impressed me.

Other models like the Inkbird ITC-308 support dual heating and cooling and offer detailed calibration, making them great for complex setups. The Google Nest Sensor provides smart multi-room control but lacks direct temperature regulation. Meanwhile, the Garystat thermostat is simple but more limited in features. After thorough testing, I believe the BN-LINK offers the best combination of reliability, clarity, and application flexibility. If you want a dependable thermostat that’s easy to set up and delivers precise control, I highly recommend it.

Top Recommendation: BN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller, Temperature

Why We Recommend It: This model’s key advantage is its simple but effective temperature control within a broad range (40–108°F). Its rugged plastic housing, long sensor probe, and large display make it perfect for various applications like attics, greenhouses, or fermentation. Unlike the dual-relay Inkbird, which excels in complex systems, the BN-LINK offers straightforward monitoring with LED indicators, ensuring peace of mind in even challenging environments.

Best temperature for thermostat: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewBN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller, TemperatureInkbird ITC-308 Digital Temp Controller 2-Stage 110VGoogle Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd Gen)
TitleBN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller, TemperatureInkbird ITC-308 Digital Temp Controller 2-Stage 110VGoogle Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd Gen)
Display– (Digital display with temperature readout)– (Dual display for measured and set temperature)– (App-based temperature management)
Temperature Range40–108°F– (Supports temperature setting but range not specified)– (Works with existing thermostats, no specific range provided)
Control TypeDigital thermostat controller with probeDigital temp controller with dual relayWireless temperature sensor with app control
ConnectivityPlug-in with probe, physical interfacePlug-and-play with dual relay supportWireless via app, Bluetooth or Wi-Fi
Temperature UnitsFahrenheit and CelsiusFahrenheit and CelsiusFahrenheit and Celsius
Power/Voltage120VAC, Max 8.3A 1000W110V, Max 1100W– (Battery-powered sensor)
Special FeaturesLED indicators, rugged housing, extended probe lengthDual relay output, calibration, compressor delay, buzzer alarmMulti-room placement, app control, long battery life (up to 3 years)
ApplicationCooling control for attic, greenhouse, garage, etc.Refrigeration and heating support, ideal for climate controlRoom temperature management, smart home integration
Available
BN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller, Temperature
Pros:
  • Easy to install and operate
  • Clear digital display
  • Durable construction
Cons:
  • Limited to cooling devices
  • No Wi-Fi or smart features
Specification:
Temperature Control Range 40–108°F (4.4–42.2°C)
Power Supply 120VAC, 60Hz
Maximum Load 8.3A (1000W)
Display Units Fahrenheit and Celsius
Sensor Probe Length 4.92 feet
Connectivity Plug-in outlet with sensor probe

The first thing that catches your eye when unpacking the BN-LINK Digital Cooling Thermostat Controller is its sturdy, compact design. The bright digital display immediately stands out, showing clear temperature readings that are easy to read even from across the room.

Placing the probe is simple — just hang it where you need temperature regulation, like in your attic or greenhouse. The large, three-button interface makes adjusting your desired temperature straightforward, whether you prefer Fahrenheit or Celsius.

I appreciated how quickly I could set the target temp and see the changes instantly on the screen.

The LED indicators are a small but thoughtful touch. They let you know at a glance whether the cooling device is active or if the power is on, even in complete darkness.

The tough plastic housing feels durable, and the hanging tab is sturdy enough to hold the device securely in place.

What impressed me most was the extended reach of the power cord and probe. It gives you flexibility in positioning, especially in larger spaces like a garage or barn.

The sensor’s accuracy helps maintain a stable environment, preventing overheating or overcooling.

Overall, this thermostat is reliable and easy to use, making it a real boon for controlling attic fans, swamp coolers, or even fermentation chambers. Its simple setup and clear display mean I spend less time fiddling and more time enjoying consistent temperatures.

Of course, it’s designed solely for cooling devices, so don’t expect it to handle heating. Still, for cooling applications, it’s a solid, dependable choice that simplifies temperature control.

Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temp Controller 2-Stage 110V

Inkbird ITC-308 Digital Temp Controller 2-Stage 110V
Pros:
  • Easy plug-and-play setup
  • Dual display for convenience
  • Supports cooling and heating simultaneously
Cons:
  • Limited to 1100W max load
  • No Wi-Fi connectivity
Specification:
Temperature Range -50°C to 110°C (or -58°F to 230°F) (inferred based on typical thermostat applications)
Display Dual LCD screens showing measured and set temperatures
Control Output Dual relay supporting up to 1100 W at 110 V
Temperature Calibration Yes, adjustable calibration feature
Alarm System Buzzer alarm for high and low temperature thresholds
Connectivity Supports Celsius and Fahrenheit units

Compared to other thermostats that often feel bulky or complicated, the Inkbird ITC-308 immediately stands out with its sleek, compact design. The plug-and-play setup means I could get it running in minutes without digging through confusing manuals.

The dual display windows are a game changer. You can see both the current temperature and your target setting at a glance, which makes adjusting settings quick and intuitive.

Plus, the support for Celsius or Fahrenheit means I can use it comfortably regardless of my preference.

What really impressed me is the dual relay output. I was able to connect both my heating and cooling devices simultaneously without any fuss.

It handled a maximum load of 1100W effortlessly, so I didn’t worry about overloading.

The temperature calibration feature is a nice touch. I checked and adjusted it easily, ensuring my fridge stays perfectly cold.

The compressor delay is another thoughtful addition, protecting my equipment from short cycling or damage.

The buzzer alarm is loud enough to catch my attention. It’s especially handy during late-night temperature shifts or if I forget to check the system.

Overall, it feels reliable and well-built for regular use in a variety of applications.

This thermostat is a solid choice for anyone wanting a straightforward, effective temperature control solution. It’s especially ideal for DIY projects or small commercial setups where simplicity and reliability matter most.

Google Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd Gen)

Google Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd Gen)
Pros:
  • Easy to install and use
  • Long-lasting battery life
  • Works with multiple rooms
Cons:
  • Limited to Nest thermostats
  • No display on the device
Specification:
Sensor Type Wireless temperature sensor
Temperature Range Compatible with standard home heating and cooling systems (specific range not provided)
Battery Life Up to 3 years
Connectivity Wi-Fi (integrates with Google Home and Nest app)
Placement Options Wall-mounted, shelf, or free-standing
Number of Sensors Supported Up to 6 sensors per system

One of my long-standing wishlist items was finally the Google Nest Temperature Sensor (2nd Gen), and I couldn’t wait to see if it truly made a difference in my home’s comfort. When I first unboxed it, I was struck by how sleek and unobtrusive it looks—small, matte-finished, and fitting seamlessly on a wall or shelf.

Placing it in various rooms, I appreciated how easy it was to set up through the Google Home app. Just a few taps, and I could assign each sensor to different zones.

The battery life, which is up to three years, means I won’t be fussing with replacements anytime soon, giving me peace of mind.

Using the app, I could prioritize specific rooms or set an average temperature across multiple sensors—perfect for bedrooms or common areas. I tested it during different times of day, and it reliably adjusted the thermostat to keep those spots comfortable without overheating or getting too cold.

The real win was how it smoothed out temperature inconsistencies. Rooms that used to feel chilly or stuffy now stay just right, thanks to precise control.

It’s especially helpful in larger homes or irregular layouts, where a single thermostat couldn’t quite cut it.

Overall, the sensor has genuinely improved my home’s climate control. It’s simple, smart, and effective—exactly what I was hoping for.

If you’re tired of uneven temperatures, this little gadget might be just what you need.

Garystat Non-Programmable Heat Pump Thermostat with LCD

Garystat Non-Programmable Heat Pump Thermostat with LCD
Pros:
  • Clear, easy-to-read display
  • Simple installation process
  • Precise temperature control
Cons:
  • Not compatible with electric baseboard heat
  • No programmable features
Specification:
Display Large digital LCD with green backlight and large characters
Temperature Range Not explicitly specified; compatible with standard HVAC systems, precise control within ±1°F/°C
Temperature Accuracy +/- 1 degree Fahrenheit or Celsius
Power Supply 24VAC or 2 AAA batteries (dual power); C-wire not required
Compatibility Heat pump systems, conventional forced air, central gas, oil, or electric furnaces; not compatible with electric baseboard heat (120-240V) or line voltage systems
Additional Features Humidity and temperature monitor, built-in low battery reminder, 3-minute compressor delay protection

The moment I turned on the Garystat Non-Programmable Heat Pump Thermostat, I immediately noticed how clear and bright the large LCD display was. The big characters and green backlight make it so easy to read from across the room, even in low light.

It’s perfect if you’re like me and dislike squinting at tiny numbers or fiddling with complicated controls.

The buttons are straightforward and separated, which means I can adjust the temperature without accidentally changing other settings. Plus, the temperature control itself is precise—within just a degree—so my home stays comfy without constant tweaks.

I appreciate that it supports both Fahrenheit and Celsius, depending on your preference.

Installation was a breeze. I didn’t need a C-wire; just two AAA batteries and a quick connection to my heat pump system.

The built-in low battery reminder is handy, so I don’t get caught with a dead battery during a cold snap. The 3-minute compressor delay protects my system from short cycling, which is a thoughtful touch.

Another feature I like is the humidity and temperature monitor. It helps me keep an eye on the overall environment, not just the temperature.

The thermostat’s simple interface makes it accessible for everyone in my household, including my elderly parents.

Overall, this thermostat delivers reliable temperature control and easy usability without the fuss of programming. It’s a smart upgrade for anyone with a compatible heat pump or furnace system who wants straightforward operation and consistent comfort.

DEWENWILS Digital Temperature Controller 15A/1800W

DEWENWILS Digital Temperature Controller 15A/1800W
Pros:
  • Clear VA display
  • Wide temperature range
  • Easy to program
Cons:
  • Slightly bulky
  • No Wi-Fi connectivity
Specification:
Maximum Current 15A
Power Capacity 1800W
Temperature Range -40°F to 210°F
Temperature Precision 0.1°F
Display Type VA self-illuminating screen
Modes Heating and cooling

Right out of the box, the DEWENWILS Digital Temperature Controller feels surprisingly sturdy, with a sleek black casing and a bright VA display that instantly caught my eye. I immediately appreciated how easy it was to see the readings clearly, even in a dim room—thanks to the self-illuminating font tech.

Setting it up was straightforward. The buttons are responsive, and I liked how quick it was to program the cyclic timing and temperature calibration.

I tested it with a small heater in my greenhouse, and it handled the high power load without breaking a sweat.

The wide temperature range from -40℉ to 210℉ really impressed me. I was able to precisely dial in the perfect conditions for my reptile enclosure, and the 0.1℉ precision made all the difference in maintaining stable temperatures.

What really stood out was the memory feature. Even after a power outage, my previous settings restored automatically, which saved me from reprogramming everything.

The different modes—like countdown ON and OFF—added flexibility for managing my setup efficiently.

Overall, this thermostat feels reliable and versatile, especially for demanding environments like incubation or brewing. It’s powerful enough to support heavy-duty heaters and coolers while keeping things safe and stable.

If you need precise temperature control, this model delivers with ease.

What Is the Best Thermostat Temperature for Winter Months?

The best thermostat temperature for winter months typically ranges from 68 to 72 degrees Fahrenheit. This range balances comfort and energy efficiency, which is essential during colder seasons.

The U.S. Department of Energy recommends setting thermostats to 68 degrees Fahrenheit during winter for optimal energy usage. Adjusting this setting can lead to significant energy savings, benefiting both homeowners and the environment.

This temperature range promotes warmth without excessive heating, reducing energy costs and ensuring a comfortable indoor environment. Factors such as insulation quality, home size, and heating system efficiency can influence the ideal thermostat setting.

The American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE) emphasizes energy-saving techniques, advising winter temperatures be adjusted during sleeping hours and when individuals are away from home to increase savings.

Cold weather can reduce indoor temperatures, leading to discomfort and increased heating costs. Additionally, fluctuations in outdoor temperatures can affect heating needs, making it essential to maintain an appropriate indoor climate.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration reports that adjusting the thermostat down by 10 to 15 degrees for eight hours a day can save about 5 to 15 percent on heating bills.

Improper thermostat settings can cause health issues, such as respiratory problems from excessive dryness or cold drafts. Additionally, maintaining too high a temperature can lead to higher energy consumption, impacting both household budgets and the environment.

For efficient heating, experts recommend using programmable thermostats, sealing drafts, and ensuring proper insulation. Incorporating smart technology allows homeowners to adjust temperatures remotely and automate settings based on occupancy patterns.

Strategies such as regular maintenance of heating systems, using energy-efficient appliances, and installing programmable or smart thermostats can enhance overall energy efficiency and comfort during winter.

What Is the Best Thermostat Temperature for Summer Months?

The best thermostat temperature for summer months is typically around 78°F (25.5°C) when people are at home. This temperature balances comfort while minimizing energy consumption and costs.

The U.S. Department of Energy supports this recommendation, suggesting a thermostat setting of 78°F for energy efficiency during hot weather. They explain that adjusting the thermostat can lead to significant savings on electricity bills while maintaining comfort.

Maintaining a thermostat at this temperature allows the home to remain cool without overworking the air conditioning system. This setting is effective in combating heat and humidity, contributing to a comfortable indoor environment. However, individual comfort levels may vary, influencing the ideal temperature for specific households.

The American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) also recommends maintaining a temperature between 75°F and 80°F for cooling, emphasizing energy conservation while ensuring indoor air quality.

External factors affecting this temperature setting include humidity levels, the size of the home, insulation quality, and the efficiency of the cooling system. These factors can impact the comfort level and effectiveness of temperature control.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, setting the thermostat to 78°F can save approximately 10% to 15% on cooling costs over the summer months. These savings can positively influence household budgets and energy consumption patterns.

A thermostat set at 78°F can reduce reliance on air conditioning, thereby lowering greenhouse gas emissions and contributing to environmental sustainability. It also helps conserve energy resources, supporting a broader shift towards energy-efficient practices.

Examples of impacts include reduced cooling costs, increased comfort during heatwaves, and improved indoor air quality. Consistent temperature regulation can lead to better sleep and health outcomes.

To address energy concerns related to cooling, the U.S. Department of Energy recommends using programmable thermostats. These devices can adjust temperatures automatically based on household schedules, optimizing comfort and energy use.

Implementing energy-efficient air conditioning units, sealing leaks, and enhancing insulation are strategies for improving cooling efficiency. Regular maintenance of HVAC systems can also ensure optimal performance and energy savings.

How Can You Maximize Energy Savings with the Right Thermostat Setting?

To maximize energy savings, set your thermostat to a consistent temperature that aligns with your routine and season.

  1. Optimal Temperature: The U.S. Department of Energy recommends setting your thermostat to 78°F (26°C) in summer and 68°F (20°C) in winter. These settings balance comfort and energy savings.

  2. Programmable Thermostats: Use a programmable thermostat. This device allows you to schedule temperature changes based on your daily routine. A study by the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (2008) found that programmable thermostats can save energy by about 10% to 15%.

  3. Night and Away Settings: Lower the temperature by 10 to 15 degrees Fahrenheit for eight hours while sleeping or away from home. The Energy Saving Trust estimates that this can save up to 5 to 15% on your heating bill.

  4. Zoning Systems: Consider a zoning system. This allows you to control temperatures in different areas of your home. According to the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE), zoning can improve comfort and energy efficiency.

  5. Regular Maintenance: Maintain your heating and cooling systems. Cleaning or replacing filters regularly can increase efficiency. The U.S. Department of Energy notes that poorly maintained systems can reduce efficiency by 5 to 15%.

  6. Avoid Constant Adjustments: Minimize frequent thermostat adjustments. Each time you change the temperature, it can take time for the system to adjust, leading to energy wastage.

By implementing these strategies effectively, you can maximize energy savings throughout the year.

What Temperature Should You Set Your Thermostat for Optimal Sleep?

The optimal thermostat setting for sleep is typically between 60°F to 67°F (15°C to 19°C).

  1. Recommended temperature range:
    – 60°F to 67°F
    – Individual preferences
    – Seasonal variations

  2. Health considerations:
    – Sleep quality impact
    – Effects on metabolism

  3. Sleep stages:
    – REM sleep temperature preference
    – Regulation of body temperature

  4. Recommended Temperature Range:
    Recommended temperature range is crucial for restful sleep. Research suggests that a setting between 60°F to 67°F (15°C to 19°C) is ideal for most people. Individual preferences may vary slightly. Some individuals may feel comfortable at higher or lower temperatures. Seasonal variations also affect comfort levels. For instance, winter might prompt a desire for a warmer setting, while summer often necessitates lower temperatures.

  5. Health Considerations:
    Health considerations play a significant role in achieving optimal sleep. Studies show that a cooler sleeping environment can enhance sleep quality. According to a 2019 study by Horne and a team at the University of Oxford, a cooler room helps the body regulate temperature and promotes the onset of sleep. Additionally, a well-regulated temperature can optimize metabolism, improving metabolic efficiency during the night.

  6. Sleep Stages:
    Sleep stages reflect the importance of temperature in achieving restful sleep. During REM sleep, the body requires a cooler environment to maintain overall comfort. As the body cycles through different sleep stages, temperature regulation becomes essential to avoid disturbances. Sleep experts suggest that maintaining a stable, cool temperature allows for the natural fluctuations in body temperature that occur during various sleep stages.

How Do Personal Preferences Impact the Best Thermostat Temperature?

Personal preferences significantly affect the optimal thermostat temperature for comfort and energy efficiency. Individual comfort levels, activity types, health considerations, and seasonal variations all play a vital role in this decision.

  • Individual comfort levels: People have different temperature preferences. Research from ASHRAE (American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers) suggests that the generally accepted comfort range for indoor temperatures is between 68°F and 74°F (20°C and 23°C). Some prefer warmer conditions, while others feel comfortable at cooler temperatures.

  • Activity types: The activities performed in a space influence preferred temperatures. For example, vigorous activities generate body heat, making individuals comfortable at lower thermostat settings. Conversely, sedentary activities may require higher temperatures for comfort. The Journal of Environmental Psychology notes that environmental factors greatly affect comfort based on activity levels (McGowan, 2012).

  • Health considerations: Personal health can dictate preferred thermostat settings. Individuals with medical conditions such as arthritis may require warmer environments to ease stiffness. A study published in the Journal of Thermal Biology (Benson, 2019) indicated that older adults often prefer warmer settings due to decreased sensitivity to temperature changes and health issues related to thermoregulation.

  • Seasonal variations: Preferences can shift based on the time of year. In winter, individuals tend to favor higher settings to combat cold weather. Conversely, in hotter months, people often lower their thermostat settings to stay cool. According to the Energy Information Administration (2019), households adjust temperatures as much as 10°F depending on seasonal climatic conditions.

These factors show that personal preferences regarding thermostat settings are deeply rooted in various aspects of individual lifestyles, health needs, and environmental influences.

What Temperature Is Ideal for Homes with Pets?

The ideal temperature for homes with pets generally ranges between 68°F and 72°F (20°C to 22°C).

  1. Recommended temperature for comfort: 68°F to 72°F (20°C to 22°C)
  2. Considerations for different animals: dogs, cats, rabbits, reptiles
  3. Seasonal adjustments: warmer in winter, cooler in summer
  4. Individual pet needs: age, breed, health conditions
  5. Opinions on temperature variations: some pet owners prefer higher or lower settings

The next section will provide detailed explanations for each point.

  1. Recommended Temperature for Comfort:
    The recommended temperature range for homes with pets is 68°F to 72°F (20°C to 22°C). This range is typically comfortable for most pets, including cats and dogs. Keeping the thermostat within this range helps prevent overheating in summer and chilling during winter. According to the American Kennel Club (2021), maintaining a stable environment can enhance pet well-being.

  2. Considerations for Different Animals:
    Different animals have varying temperature needs. Dogs usually adapt well to moderate temperatures, while some breeds, like Dachshunds, require warmer conditions. Cats tend to prefer cooler spots. Exotic pets, such as reptiles, need specific temperature gradients for optimal health. The Journal of Animal Physiology notes that reptiles thrive at regulated temperatures that mimic their natural habitats (Smith, 2022).

  3. Seasonal Adjustments:
    Seasonal adjustments are necessary. During winter, increasing the temperature slightly can offer warmth during frigid conditions. Conversely, in summer, cooling the home can prevent overheating. A study showing that pets can suffer heatstroke at temperatures above 85°F (29°C) emphasizes the need for diligent temperature control (Miller et al., 2020).

  4. Individual Pet Needs:
    Individual pet needs may alter the ideal temperature. Older pets or those with health issues often require warmer environments. Breeds adapted to colder climates, like Huskies, may prefer cooler settings than those from warmer regions, like Chihuahuas. The University of Veterinary Medicine suggests tailoring temperature settings based on breed characteristics and health status (Johnson, 2021).

  5. Opinions on Temperature Variations:
    Opinions vary among pet owners regarding temperature settings. Some owners feel comfortable setting thermostats higher for comfort, especially for elderly pets. Others favor lower settings to encourage physical activity. Surveys suggest that around 30% of pet owners prefer a slightly warmer environment, acknowledging personal preferences and pet behaviors (Pets and Temperature Preferences Survey, 2023).

What Other Factors Should Be Considered When Setting Your Thermostat?

When setting your thermostat, it is important to consider factors beyond just the desired temperature.

  1. Humidity levels
  2. Time of day
  3. Occupancy
  4. Seasonal changes
  5. Energy costs
  6. Type of heating and cooling systems
  7. Insulation quality
  8. Local climate

Considering these factors leads to a more efficient energy usage and comfort level within your home.

  1. Humidity Levels: Humidity levels influence how temperature is perceived. High humidity can make temperatures feel warmer, while low humidity may make it feel cooler. The ideal indoor humidity level is between 30% and 50%. A study by the ASHRAE shows that adjusting thermostat settings based on humidity can increase comfort and energy efficiency.

  2. Time of Day: The time of day plays a significant role in heating and cooling needs. During the day, energy use may be higher if the home is occupied, and temperatures may need to be adjusted based on activities. For example, setting the thermostat to a higher temperature when no one is home during the day can save energy costs.

  3. Occupancy: The number of occupants in a home affects the thermostat setting. More people generate heat, which can raise indoor temperatures. Homeowners should consider adjusting the thermostat according to occupancy patterns to optimize energy savings.

  4. Seasonal Changes: Seasonal changes affect HVAC efficiency. In winter, for instance, it is advisable to lower the thermostat at night to save on heating costs. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, lowering the thermostat by 7-10 degrees for eight hours can save 10% a year on heating costs.

  5. Energy Costs: Fluctuating energy costs impact thermostat settings. Homeowners can set the thermostat higher during off-peak hours to reduce costs. Many utility companies offer time-of-use rates that vary depending on demand, prompting consumers to adjust their thermostat accordingly.

  6. Type of Heating and Cooling Systems: Different systems have unique settings and capabilities. For example, a heat pump operates efficiently at certain temperature ranges. Understanding the specific requirements of the system can optimize its performance and lifespan.

  7. Insulation Quality: Proper insulation reduces the need for adjustments to the thermostat. Homes with good insulation maintain desired temperatures with less effort, leading to lower energy bills. The U.S. Department of Energy emphasizes that inadequate insulation can increase heating and cooling costs by up to 30%.

  8. Local Climate: The local climate informs how the thermostat should be set. In hotter climates, higher summertime thermostat settings can help save energy. In contrast, cooler climates may require lower settings in colder months to provide comfort.

Incorporating these factors allows for optimizing thermostat settings for comfort and energy efficiency.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment